4.9

Google Reviews

Need Help? Contact An Australian Business Lawyer Today 1300 003 077

Can you rely on AI for Australian Legal Advice?

Reading time: 7 mins

Artificial Intelligence (AI) platforms are making legal information more accessible than ever.

A person can now ask a question about their employment, a commercial dispute or a contract and receive a detailed response within seconds.

In many respects, that is a positive development, especially giving people greater access to information about their rights and obligations.

But access to legal information is not the same thing as access to reliable legal advice.

And courts and lawyers are already dealing with some of the consequences.

Australian courts are already dealing with AI mistakes

Generative AI in law can produce information that looks completely legitimate but isn’t.

That includes legal authorities and case citations. AI provides the name of a case, explain what supposedly happened and confidently tell you that the case supports your argument.

However, AI can ‘hallucinate’ cases to appease you. This is dangerous in law because the courts rely heavily on previous cases and legal authorities. AI’s ability to produce something that looks like a legitimate citation can therefore create serious problems when the information isn’t independently checked.

The risks of relying on AI for legal information are no longer hypothetical. Australian courts have already dealt with cases where AI has generated legal authorities and case citations that simply did not exist.

One example is Handa & Mallick [2024] FedCFamC2F 957, the Court was provided a list of cases for a family court matter. However, when the Court tried to verify the cases, when checked, it discovered that the citations related to completely different cases.

A similar issue arose in Mertz & Mertz (No 3) [2025] FedCFamC1A 222. AI was used in preparing court documents that contained legal authorities that were inaccurate, misleading or did not exist. Errors remained even after amended documents were filed.

The consequences were significant. The payment associated to correct the problem amounted to an extra $10,000 in additional costs.

The underlying lesson is if you are representing yourself with no legal counsel, you remain responsible for what you submit.

AI can assist with the process, but it does not replace an experienced lawyer’s professional judgment. Our lawyers would verify the law, apply it to your circumstances and thoroughly review the advice and documents we prepare.

Why does AI sound so convincing when it is wrong?

Part of the problem is that an AI tool and a lawyer are performing fundamentally different roles.

AI is designed to generate a useful response to what you ask it.

A lawyer has another responsibility. They assess your circumstances against the law and exercise independent professional judgment.

Great legal advice shows there the problems with your argument or whether the law doesn’t support the outcome you’re hoping for.

This is what we consider a “reality check” if AI becomes involved. AI can construct an argument but that does not mean the argument will survive proper legal scrutiny.

When AI misses the legal context

We are seeing this more and more in our practice. For example, an AI tool might confidently tell an employee that they have a strong unfair dismissal claim without first checking whether they have completed the minimum employment period (generally six months, or 12 months where the employer is a small business).

An employer might similarly ask an AI tool how to terminate an employee and follow its generic steps without checking the Fair Work Act, the applicable award or enterprise agreement, the employment contract, notice and final-pay obligations, or the particular circumstances of the dismissal.

The same risk arises in general contract drafting. A business might use AI to prepare a services agreement that appears comprehensive but contains a liability cap copied from an overseas template, fails to deal with ownership of intellectual property created under the engagement, or omits a practical termination right. The drafting may sound authoritative, yet leave the business exposed because the clauses have not been tailored to Australian law or the commercial deal.

How does Prosper Law use AI?

Like almost every industry, the legal profession is being transformed by AI. It is increasingly being incorporated into the software, research tools and systems lawyers use every day.

The important distinction is how AI is used.

At our firm, AI does not replace the professional judgment of our lawyers. Our lawyers remain accountable for the advice we provide.  They independently review and verify any AI-assisted work. This includes checking the accuracy of legal information, applying the law to the circumstances of each matter and maintaining our obligations around client confidentiality and privacy.

Being human-centred is an important part of how we practise law. Your matter is considered by a lawyer, not handed over to AI to make decisions about your legal position.

We also recognise the benefits that technology provides. When used appropriately, AI can assist with certain legal and administrative tasks, allowing our lawyers to work more efficiently and spend more time on the areas that require legal expertise, strategy and professional judgment.

And importantly, when technology enables us to complete certain tasks more efficiently, that efficiency is reflected in the time spent on your matter and, where we charge based on time, the fees you pay.

For us, it is not about choosing between AI and experienced lawyers. It is about using technology where it adds value, while keeping experienced lawyers firmly responsible for the legal work and advice you receive.

When the decision could materially affect your business, your money or your legal rights, independent professional judgment still matters.

Although the AI tools we use operate within closed systems, we also respect clients who ask us not to use AI for their matter.

If AI has helped you identify a legal issue but you’re unsure whether the answer is legally correct or applies to your situation, contact us to speak with one of our professional lawyers to help you understand your options before you act.

Prosper Law staff help with legal risks for buyers in small business sales

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use AI to review a contract before I sign it?

AI may help explain unfamiliar terms or identify clauses you might want to investigate further, but it may not identify how those clauses affect your legal or commercial position.

Before signing an important agreement, contact our commercial contract lawyers, who can review the contract, explain your obligations and identify risks or clauses that may need to be negotiated or amended.

What should I do if ChatGPT gives me legal information that conflicts with what my lawyer says?

Ask your lawyer to explain the difference. An AI response may not have all the facts, may be applying law from a different jurisdiction or may be relying on inaccurate or outdated information.

If you have relied on AI to research a legal issue and want a second opinion, our experienced lawyers can review the information, explain the relevant Australian law and help you understand your options.

Is information I enter into an AI platform confidential?

You should not automatically assume that information entered a public AI platform has the same confidentiality protections as information you provide directly to your lawyer.

Before uploading contracts, correspondence, personal information or details about a legal dispute, consider what information you are providing and how the AI platform handles that data. If you are unsure about the privacy or legal implications of using AI with sensitive business information, contact Prosper Law so we can help you understand the risks.

When should I speak to a lawyer instead of relying on AI?

Consider speaking with a lawyer when a decision could significantly affect your legal rights, finances or business, particularly before signing an important agreement, commencing or responding to legal proceedings, sending significant legal correspondence or taking an action that may be difficult to reverse.

If AI has helped you identify the issue, but you are unsure what to do next, speak with one of our experienced lawyers. We can review your circumstances, explain your legal position and help you decide on the appropriate next steps.

About the Author

Picture of Farrah Motley
Farrah Motley
Director of Prosper Law. Farrah founded Prosper online law firm in 2021. She wanted to create a better way of doing legal work and a better experience for customers of legal services.

Contact an Australian Business Lawyer Today.

Contact us for a free consultation

Contact Us For A Free Legal Consultation
About Prosper Law

We provide legal advice to business and individuals across Australia, no matter which State or Territory you are located. Our easy-to-access, online legal services mean that you can talk to our lawyers wherever you are, at a time that suits you.

4.9

Google Reviews

Get Your Free Guide Now
Need Legal Assistance?

Don’t hesitate – reach out for your free legal assistance today. Your peace of mind is just a click or call away!

Check Out Our Latest Blog Posts

Allison Inskip is a Senior Paralegal and highly experienced legal professional
Business

The Contract Clauses CEOs Can’t Ignore

For CEOs and executives, every contract signed has ripple effects far beyond the legal department. Contracts define partnerships, control cash flow, and set the boundaries of risk. Yet in the

Farrah Motley is an Australian Qualified Lawyer
Legal Counsel

What Does In-House Legal Counsel Do?

Updated November 2026 What does in-house legal counsel do? An in-house legal counsel is a lawyer employed by a business to manage its legal work from the inside: reviewing and