“No refunds on sale items.” “Our liability is limited to the 12-month manufacturer’s warranty.” “Items must be returned unopened.”
Clauses like these turn up in a surprising number of terms and conditions, returns pages and customer service emails. They usually get there for understandable reasons. Someone copied a template, or wanted to stop people returning things they had simply changed their mind about. But in Australia, they can turn an ordinary customer complaint into a regulator problem.
In September 2026, an online retailer of weighted blankets and sensory mats paid $59,400 in infringement notices to the ACCC. One customer had said a mat would not lie flat and was a tripping hazard. Another said it was shorter than described on the website. The emails they received in reply allegedly suggested that refunds were discretionary, that products had to be unused and that customers could be charged for return shipping. The case shows how routine complaint responses can create regulatory risk when they suggest that remedies are discretionary or subject to conditions that do not reflect the consumer guarantees.
The direct answer: no, but you may be able to limit what you owe
You cannot contract out of the consumer guarantees. Section 64 of the Australian Consumer Law (Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)) makes any term that tries to exclude, restrict or modify them void. It does not matter that the customer ticked a box, signed the order form or was told about the term in advance.
The guarantees are the baseline promises that come with goods and services sold to consumers. Goods must be of acceptable quality, fit for any purpose the customer made known, and match their description. Services must be provided with due care and skill and within a reasonable time. If something goes wrong, the customer may be entitled to a repair, replacement, refund or compensation, depending on whether the failure is major or minor.
It is easy to assume this only matters when selling to the public. It does not. A “consumer” includes a business that buys goods or services costing $100,000 or less, and anyone who buys goods or services of a kind ordinarily acquired for personal, domestic or household use, whatever the price. A café buying a $3,000 coffee grinder, or a tradie buying a ute, is likely to be a consumer for these purposes.
The bigger risk is often not the void clause itself, but what it says to customers. Telling someone they have no right to a remedy when the law gives them one may be a false or misleading representation under section 29(1)(m). Since 28 March 2026, the maximum penalty for a company for that kind of conduct is the greatest of $100 million (doubled from $50 million), three times the benefit obtained or, if the benefit cannot be determined, 30% of adjusted turnover during the breach period. The ACCC also has infringement notices available for smaller matters, which is how the blanket retailer’s case was dealt with.
More change is coming. In late 2025, Consumer Ministers agreed to introduce civil penalties for businesses that fail to provide consumer guarantee remedies, along with expanded enforcement powers. At the time of writing, draft legislation has not been released, but the reform signals that refusing a valid claim, and not just misdescribing the law, may soon carry penalties of its own.

When limiting your liability may work
There is one main pathway. Under section 64A, a supplier may limit its liability for a breach of a consumer guarantee, but only where the goods or services are not of a kind ordinarily acquired for personal, domestic or household use. For goods, liability can be limited to replacing or repairing them, supplying equivalent goods, or paying the cost of doing so. For services, it can be limited to supplying the services again or paying the cost of having them supplied again.
Even then, the limitation may not apply if the customer can show that relying on it would not be fair or reasonable. The court may look at the relative bargaining strength of the parties, whether the customer could have bought the same thing elsewhere without the limitation, whether they knew about the term, and whether the goods were made or adapted to their special order.
Example: Limiting liability for commercial equipment
A supplier sells a commercial refrigeration unit to a regional butcher for $42,000. The unit is not something people ordinarily buy for home, and the butcher is a consumer only because the price is under $100,000. A clear term limiting the supplier’s liability to repairing or replacing the unit may be effective. But if the unit fails in a heatwave and the butcher loses a week of stock, the supplier is likely to face an argument that relying on the limitation is not fair or reasonable, particularly if the term was buried in small print and the butcher had no real choice of supplier. The limitation helps, but it is not a guarantee.
Outside the consumer guarantees altogether, there is more room to move. Where a business buys goods costing more than $100,000 that are not ordinarily acquired for household use, or buys goods to resell them or use them up in manufacturing, the guarantees generally do not apply. In those cases, the parties can usually allocate risk in their contract, although state sale of goods laws, the unfair contract terms regime and the general prohibition on misleading conduct still sit in the background.
When it does not work
Most problems tend to fall into a few familiar patterns, and the clause in the terms is often only part of the story.
The first is the one-size-fits-all policy. A business that sells both to households and to other businesses often uses the same terms for everyone. A section 64A limitation may be valid for the commercial customer, but it is unlikely to help with the household customer, and a blanket statement that “liability is limited to repair or replacement” may mislead the people it cannot lawfully apply to.
The second is the warranty that pretends to be the whole story. A manufacturer’s warranty is an extra promise that sits on top of the consumer guarantees, not instead of them. A product can still fail the acceptable quality guarantee after a 12-month warranty has expired, depending on what a reasonable consumer would expect of it. Businesses that offer a warranty against defects must also include the mandatory wording set out in the Competition and Consumer Regulations 2010 (Cth), which explains that the warranty is in addition to the customer’s rights under the Australian Consumer Law. The blanket retailer’s third infringement notice was for leaving that wording out.
The third is the instruction that sends the customer somewhere else. “Please contact the manufacturer.” “Sale items cannot be returned.” “Using a third-party repairer voids your warranty.” Each of these has led to ACCC action over the years, including a $9 million penalty against Apple over statements about third-party repairs. A retailer can choose to involve the manufacturer, but it cannot insist that the customer deal with them instead.
Example: When customer communications contradict your terms
An online fitness equipment store has carefully drafted terms with a proper saving clause stating that nothing excludes the customer’s rights under the Australian Consumer Law. A customer’s rowing machine develops a fault after 14 months. The customer service team, working from an old email template, replies that the item is “out of warranty” and offers a 20% discount on a new one. The terms were fine. The email was the problem, and it is the email the customer forwards to the ACCC.
A useful saving clause makes clear that nothing in the contract excludes, restricts or modifies rights that cannot lawfully be excluded, including rights under the Australian Consumer Law. It is worth having, but it is unlikely to cure a message that says the opposite everywhere else. Regulators tend to look at the overall impression a business creates, across its website, its terms, its staff and its emails, not just at the one sentence that gets the law right. Specific provisions dealing with refunds, time limits, return costs, inspection requirements and manufacturer warranties should still be reviewed, because a prominent unlawful restriction may create a misleading overall impression despite the saving clause.
Our take: where to look first
If you are reviewing your own position, it may help to look in three places, in this order:
- Start with what your staff actually say. Customer service templates, chat scripts, returns pages and website FAQs are where most of the risk tends to sit, because they are written quickly, rarely reviewed by a lawyer and sent to real customers every day.
- Then look at your warranty documents, including whether the mandatory wording is there and whether the warranty is presented as an addition to the consumer guarantees rather than a substitute for them.
- Finally, look at your terms and conditions, and whether any limitation of liability is drafted to apply only where the law allows it.
For businesses that sell to other businesses, it is also worth asking which of your customers are likely to be consumers under the $100,000 threshold, and whether your terms treat them differently. A well-drafted section 64A clause can give real protection, but only if it is aimed at the right customers.
In our experience, a common issue is a retailer treating the manufacturer’s warranty as the customer’s only remedy (effectively passing the complaint on to the manufacturer) or relying on a blanket “no returns” policy. Clients are often surprised to learn that, as the seller, they remain responsible for providing any remedy required by the consumer guarantees, regardless of what the manufacturer’s warranty says. That does not always mean the retailer carries the cost alone. Where the failure relates to the quality, fitness or description of the goods, the retailer may be able to recover its costs from the manufacturer under the Australian Consumer Law’s supplier indemnification provisions. Once that distinction is clear, most clients recognise that their terms, returns policy and customer service scripts need to work together rather than shift responsibility elsewhere.
When a complaint comes in, a practical first response is to identify what has gone wrong, what the customer expected, and whether the failure may be major or minor. A major failure can include a problem that would have stopped a reasonable consumer, fully aware of it, from buying the product. It can also include a product that is substantially unfit for its normal purpose and cannot easily be fixed, or one that is unsafe. The customer may generally reject goods with a major failure and choose a refund or replacement, although that right can be lost in some circumstances, for example where the rejection period has passed or the goods were damaged after delivery for reasons unrelated to the fault. For a minor failure, the supplier will usually have an opportunity to provide a remedy within a reasonable time. Customer service teams should avoid promising or refusing a particular outcome until that assessment has been made.
Businesses should also document the assessment behind each disputed claim. Keep the customer’s description of the problem, photographs or test results, purchase and delivery records, relevant representations made before sale, repair history, and the reasons for the proposed remedy. Escalate complaints involving safety issues, repeated product failures, significant consequential loss, vulnerable customers or a threatened regulator complaint before sending a final response.

Next steps
A quick audit can help assess what gaps you might have or what you need to do first. Let’s start with a few simple questions for you to consider:
- Does your returns policy clearly separate change-of-mind returns from faulty goods?
- Do your staff templates treat an expired warranty as the end of the enquiry, or automatically redirect customers to the manufacturer?
- Is any section 64A limitation confined to eligible goods or services, and do your warranty documents contain the required Australian Consumer Law wording?
- Do your complaint records show consistent decisions across phone, email, chat and in-store channels?
Our commercial team regularly reviews terms and conditions, returns policies, warranty documents and customer service templates for Australian businesses, and can help you respond if the ACCC or a customer raises a concern. To discuss your terms or a customer complaint, speak with our ecommerce legal team on 1300 003 077 or at enquiry@prosperlaw.com.au.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can my business have a no refunds policy?
Not for every type of return. You can generally decline refunds for change of mind, as long as you are clear that this does not affect the customer’s rights if the product is faulty, not as described or not fit for purpose. A blanket “no refunds” sign or statement may be misleading because it suggests customers have no rights at all.
Learn more in our article on refund rules every retailer must know.
Do consumer guarantees apply to business customers?
They can. A business is likely to be a consumer if it buys goods or services costing $100,000 or less, or of a kind ordinarily acquired for personal, domestic or household use, unless it buys the goods to resell them or use them up in manufacturing or repairs. For example, a café that buys a $15,000 commercial coffee machine for use in its own business is likely to be a consumer because the price is below $100,000. The consumer guarantees may therefore apply even though both parties are businesses. By contrast, a distributor that buys the same machines to resell them to cafés is generally not a consumer for those purchases because the goods were acquired for resale.
What is the difference between a warranty and a consumer guarantee?
A consumer guarantee is a right that exists by law and cannot be excluded. A warranty is an additional promise made by the business or manufacturer. A warranty can add to the customer’s rights but cannot take any of them away.
Does it matter if the customer signed the terms?
Not for the consumer guarantees. A term that tries to exclude, restrict or modify them is void under section 64 of the ACL, whether or not the customer agreed to it.
What can happen if my terms get this wrong?
The term itself is likely to be void. Separately, telling customers they have fewer rights than they do may be a false or misleading representation, which can lead to infringement notices, court-ordered penalties and orders to compensate affected customers.
About the Author

Farrah Motley
Contact an Australian Business Lawyer Today.
Contact us for a free consultation



