If a new hire signs an employment contract and then changes their mind before starting, they have usually breached the contract. However, that doesn’t mean you’ll get much back.
That’s the frustrating part. You’ve run the recruitment process, turned away the runner-up and (often) told the team that help is on the way. Then an email arrives a week before the start date. A better offer. A counter-offer from their current employer. Or nothing at all – they just don’t turn up.
The law gives you a claim. In practice, it’s rarely worth pursuing. Your real protection sits in two places: the contract, and what you do between the day they sign and the day they start. This article covers both, along with what changed in 2026.
Is a signed employment contract binding before the start date?
Yes. A contract is formed when an offer is accepted without any qualification. The start date is just one of the terms of that contract. It isn’t the moment the contract comes into existence.
Acceptance doesn’t even have to be in writing. It can be oral, or implied from conduct (turning up to work the next morning, for instance). Writing is still best practice, because when there’s a dispute about what was agreed, the paper trail usually decides it. If you’re still sending offer letters rather than full contracts, the difference between an offer letter and an employment contract matters here too.
Here’s where it gets interesting. A binding contract isn’t the same thing as an employment relationship. In Perri v Oral Health Victoria [2026] FWC 507, a patient access officer signed her contract on 31 October 2025 to start on 1 December. Her pre-employment checks came back clean, she resigned from her previous job in reliance on the contract, and she received a warm welcome email with her first-day instructions. The next day, the offer was withdrawn ‘following a due diligence process’. The Commission found there was a contract for future employment but no employment relationship, so she hadn’t been ‘dismissed’ and couldn’t bring a general protections dismissal claim.
The reasoning is worth knowing. If employment started the day the contract was signed, an employee’s service (and their entitlements) would start accruing before they’d done any work. In Ms Perri’s case, she would have been employed by two employers at once, because she was still working out her old job. A Full Bench made the same point in Kelly v Melba Support Services Australia Ltd [2021] FWCFB 4845: an employer that withdraws an offer after the contract is made may be liable for breach of contract, but the employment relationship never comes into existence.
Why does that matter to you? Because many of the rules employers rely on are triggered by employment, not by the contract. Award notice-of-resignation clauses, deductions from final pay and unfair dismissal all assume the person is already working for you. Between signing and starting, most of them don’t apply. What governs that gap is the contract itself, so whatever you want to happen in that period needs to be written into it.
There is an exception. In Argentier v City Perfume Retail Pty Ltd [2023] FWC 1819, a new casual had completed onboarding, had access to the rostering app and was told to attend ‘mandatory’ training before her first shift. The Commission found she was already an employee. In Perri, the Commission distinguished that case: the role there was casual, onboarding was complete and she had already been rostered and directed to attend training. The more you treat a new hire like staff before day one, the more likely it is that their employment has already begun.
And if the contract is ‘subject to’ something (a police check, right to work, references, a professional registration), the wording decides whether there is no contract until the condition is met, or a contract that can be ended if it isn’t. That distinction matters a lot if the condition is still outstanding when someone wants out.
Can you sue a new hire who backs out?
Technically, yes. Refusing to perform a contract before performance is due is a repudiation (in plain terms, a refusal to be bound). You can accept it, treat the contract as over and claim damages.
The problem is what those damages are worth. Damages for breach of contract aim to put you in the position you’d have been in if the contract had been performed (Robinson v Harman (1848) 1 Ex 850). But if the contract had been performed, the employee could still have resigned on notice. So you don’t recover the cost of losing the hire. You recover the loss caused by the missing notice. Recruitment costs you’d have incurred anyway (because you’d have had to replace them after they resigned) usually aren’t recoverable, you have to prove every dollar you claim, and you’re expected to take reasonable steps to reduce your loss.
Follow that through and the numbers rarely work. A few weeks of agency fees or temporary cover, minus whatever you could have avoided, set against legal fees that start well above that. One leading employment law commentary puts it bluntly: suing would have little effect unless the employee was a valuable entity, its example being a movie star.
What about making them turn up? Courts won’t order anyone to work for you. And the notice rules most employers think of don’t help much either. The National Employment Standards notice requirement (s 117 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)) applies to employers, not employees. Award resignation clauses apply to employees covered by the award, and the usual remedy (a deduction of up to a week’s wages) comes out of the employee’s final pay. Someone who never starts has no final pay to deduct from.
Even when an employer does win, the money doesn’t always go to them. In Jetgo Australia Holdings Pty Ltd v Goodsall (No 2) [2015] FCCA 1911, a pilot resigned without giving the notice the award required. The Court imposed a penalty of $2,550, payable to the Commonwealth, not the employer.
Q: Can I go after the competitor who poached them?
A: In theory. A business that knowingly persuades someone to break their contract with you can be liable for inducing a breach of contract, but you’d have to prove it knew about the contract and intended the breach (Zhu v Treasurer of New South Wales (2004) 218 CLR 530). A firm letter is usually as far as that’s worth taking.
My view? Unless the hire was going to deliver something specific you can put a dollar figure on (they were named in a tender, or a client engagement depended on them starting), suing is rarely worth it. Your time is better spent on the contract and the process, which is where the rest of this article goes.
What you can actually recover
If damages are a weak lever, a well-drafted repayment clause is a strong one. The money you’re most likely to get back is money you paid out before the person started, as long as the contract clearly says it’s repayable.
That covers things like a sign-on bonus, a relocation allowance or flights paid in advance. The safest way to draft these is as an advance that becomes repayable if the employee doesn’t start, or leaves within a set period, on a sliding scale. For example:
“If you do not commence employment on the Commencement Date, or your employment ends within 12 months of that date (other than because we terminate it without cause), you must repay a pro rata portion of the relocation allowance, calculated on the number of whole months remaining in that 12-month period.”
The bolded part is what makes it defensible. A clause like this is less likely to be struck down as a penalty, which is a payment out of all proportion to the interest it protects (Andrews v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (2012) 247 CLR 205; Paciocco v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (2016) 258 CLR 525). A fixed sum for not starting (“you must pay us $10,000 if you don’t commence”) is much harder to justify. If a clause is a penalty, it’s unenforceable. If it’s unenforceable, it was pointless putting it in.
Training costs work the same way, but put them in a separate, signed agreement that sets out the cost, the trigger and the sliding scale. Repayment claims tend to fail when the employer can’t prove the employee actually agreed to repay.
One cost you can’t recover at all: visa sponsorship. The Migration Regulations prohibit sponsors from passing on sponsorship-related costs (including nomination fees and the Skilling Australians Fund levy) to the sponsored worker, even if the worker agrees. A clawback clause for those costs isn’t just unenforceable. It can put your sponsorship at risk.
Finally, think about what the new hire has seen. If they had access to pricing, tender documents or client information before they withdrew, your protection comes from confidentiality obligations that apply from the day they sign, not from a post-employment restraint. Non-compete clauses are difficult to enforce against someone who never started, and the Federal Government’s proposed ban (discussed below) will make them harder still for most employees.

When nobody is at fault
Not every withdrawal is a change of heart. Sometimes something outside both parties’ control knocks the contract over before the start date, and the longer the gap between signing and starting, the more likely that becomes.
We recently advised an overseas-trained professional who had signed a contract many months before relocating to Australia. After signing, the relevant regulator changed the registration pathway the whole arrangement had been built around. The contract made registration a condition of employment, and even tied the pay increases to the old pathway’s timeline, but it set no deadline for meeting the condition. The new pathway was longer, involved more supervision and didn’t fit the contract as written.
So what happens then? A few principles come into play:
- where a condition has no deadline, the law implies that it must be met within a reasonable time. If it isn’t, either party may be able to end the contract without liability;
- where an unforeseen event makes performance impossible or radically different from what was agreed, the contract may be frustrated, which releases both parties from their future obligations;
- every employment contract carries an implied duty to cooperate, so an employer can’t sit on its hands while a condition it could help satisfy goes unmet. That duty is limited by commercial reasonableness (the employer doesn’t have to spend disproportionate amounts or guarantee the outcome); and
- if the employer has spent money preparing for the hire, it can only recover that money if the contract says so.
The lessons for employers are practical. Give every condition a sunset date. Say who has to do what to satisfy it. Say what happens to costs already incurred if the condition fails. And if the start date is months away, assume something will change in between.
Thankfully, our client was able to identify a new, alternative regulatory pathway and was able to follow through with the employment agreement.
What if you're the one who changes your mind?
The legal risk is far more lopsided when the employer withdraws. A candidate who backs out usually costs you little in damages. An employer who withdraws an accepted offer can cost itself a great deal more.
Withdrawing an accepted, unconditional offer is a breach of contract, unless you end it the way the contract allows (usually by giving notice, or paying in lieu of notice). Damages usually start at the notice period. They can go higher where the candidate resigned a secure job, relocated, or was promised a minimum term.
Perri confirms that a candidate whose offer is withdrawn before they start usually can’t bring a dismissal claim, because they were never employed. But that’s not the end of it. The general protections in the Fair Work Act extend to prospective employees, so refusing to employ someone (or withdrawing their offer) because of a protected attribute or because they exercised a workplace right is still unlawful (see, for example, ss 342, 346 and 351). The Commission in Perri expressly left that door open. Asking whether pre-start training would be paid is a good example of something that might amount to a workplace right. And anything you said during recruitment that misled the candidate about the job can be misleading conduct under the Australian Consumer Law (s 31 deals specifically with misleading job seekers).
If you genuinely need to withdraw, rely only on the conditions in the contract, and only for the reasons they cover. Pulling an offer ‘subject to references’ because the project fell through is not the same thing, and a UK tribunal recently found it to be a breach in exactly those circumstances (Kankanalapalli v Loesche Energy Systems Ltd, persuasive only in Australia).
What's changed in 2026
A few developments this year affect the period between signing and starting:
- Perri v Oral Health Victoria [2026] FWC 507 (February 2026) confirmed the ‘contract but no employment relationship’ position for the gap before the start date;
- the Workplace Relations Legislation Amendment (Building Cooperative Workplaces No. 1) Act 2026 changed how the Commission handles general protections disputes from 7 July 2026, including allowing some dismissal disputes to proceed on an alleged dismissal. Claims like the one in Perri may now get further before the jurisdictional question is decided;
- the high income threshold rose to $190,100 on 1 July 2026;
- payday super started on 1 July 2026, so even a hire who leaves in their first week triggers super on their final pay under the new, shorter timeframes; and
- the Federal Government released an exposure draft bill on 7 September 2026 to ban non-compete clauses for employees earning under the high income threshold, intended to start in 2027. It isn’t law yet, and the detail may change.
How to protect your business
There’s no reliable Australian data on how often new hires back out after signing. One large US study tracked more than 157,000 accepted job offers and found about 1 in 25 new hires never turned up (Speer et al, Human Resource Management Journal, 2026). Whatever the exact figure here, the fix is the same: make backing out less attractive, and make the gap shorter and more engaged.
This is the order I’d work through:
- Finish your checks (police, right to work, qualifications, references, registration) before you send the contract, not after.
- Where a condition can’t be met before signing, list it specifically, give it a sunset date and say who must do what to satisfy it.
- Make the notice clause apply both before and after the commencement date. Most templates only refer to ending ’employment’, which arguably doesn’t bite until day one. Our guide to employment contract clauses covers the rest.
- State a numerical notice period. A clause that is vague or missing invites a court to imply ‘reasonable notice’, which can be far longer.
- Treat sign-on bonuses and relocation payments as advances, repayable on a sliding scale if the person doesn’t start or leaves early.
- Put training repayment in a separate, signed agreement, and never include a clawback of visa sponsorship costs.
- Make confidentiality obligations apply from signing, and don’t share confidential information before day one unless you need to.
- Shorten the gap between signing and starting where you can. Where you can’t, keep in regular contact (a call from the manager, an invitation to a team lunch, paid induction material).
- Ask about counter-offers at the offer stage, and confirm the candidate has actually resigned from their current role.
- Keep the runner-up warm until the new hire has started, and check that any recruitment agency’s replacement guarantee covers a candidate who withdraws before starting.
- Don’t direct unpaid pre-start training or roster a new hire before their start date unless you’re comfortable that their employment has begun (Argentier).
And if someone does withdraw? Confirm in writing that you accept their withdrawal as ending the contract, ask for repayment of any advances the contract allows you to recover, ask for the return of any property or information, and keep a record of your costs. Then make a commercial decision. Most of the time, that decision is to move on.
Frequently asked questions
Is a signed job offer legally binding in Australia?
Yes. Once an offer is accepted without qualification, there’s a binding contract, even if the start date is months away.
Can an employer sue you for not starting a job?
Yes, but the damages are usually limited to the loss caused by not giving notice, which is often small. Few employers find it worth pursuing.
Do you have to give notice if you haven't started yet?
Only if the contract requires notice before the commencement date. Award notice requirements generally assume the employment has already started.
Can an employer withdraw a job offer after it has been accepted?
Only in line with the contract, usually by giving or paying the notice it requires. Otherwise, the employer may be liable for breach of contract, and possibly under the general protections or the Australian Consumer Law.
Can an employer make a new hire repay visa sponsorship costs?
No. Sponsors can’t pass sponsorship-related costs on to the sponsored worker, even if the worker agrees.
How can Prosper Law help?
Our employment law team for employers drafts employment contracts that deal with the gap between signing and starting, including notice, conditions and repayment clauses that hold up. If a new hire has just pulled out (or you’re thinking of withdrawing an offer), talk to us before you respond. Contact us.
About the Author

Farrah Motley
Contact an Australian Business Lawyer Today.
Contact us for a free consultation

