1300 003 077

Your Ultimate Guide to Set-Off and Set-off Clauses

Setting off, offset and netting all refer to the legal mechanism of applying one outstanding amount against another. The net amount (if any) is then payable to the relevant party after the application of the offset.

A set-off clause in a contract will entitle one or both parties to apply any debts they are owed against any payments due to the other party. By using contractual set-off, only the net amount (after applying the set-off), if any, will be payable by one party to the other.

If you don’t have an express right under a contract to set-off, then you may be able to rely upon the law of equity.

In this guide, we’ll step you through set-off under contract, as well as equitable set-off.

online law firm

Author: Farrah Motley, Director of Prosper Law.

What is an example of a set-off clause?

Below is an example of a set-off clause:

Party A may set-off and apply against any amounts due to Party B, any amount, claim, loss, damage, cost or expense that is or may be owed by Party B to Party A. If, after applying the set-off, an amount is still due to Party A, Party A may recover that amount from Party B. Nothing in this clause limits or reduces Party A’s rights at law to recover an amount owed by Party B.

What is an example of a set-off?

As an example:

Party A owes $100 to Party B for services performed by Party B. At the same time, Party B has caused a loss to Party A and the claim is worth $50. Party A uses the set-off clause under the contract and applies the $50 against the $100 owed to Party B. As a consequence, Party A pays the net amount of $50 to Party B.

What is Contractual Set-Off?

Can you set off without a set-off clause?

If there is no set-off clause in a contract, a party may be able to rely upon a right to set-off in the law of equity. However, this is not available in every instance and the party seeking to set off needs to use this right carefully.

When is equitable set-off available?

If a contract doesn’t contain a set-off clause, a party may be able to rely on the law of equity (this is a different area of law to contract law) to lawfully effect a set-off.

The law of equitable may be able to be relied upon if it would be unconscionable to allow one party to insist on its legal right without first taking into account the other party’s legal right.

Goldsmith v AMP Life Limited

In Goldsmith v AMP Life Limited, a dispute between a landlord and tenant led to the restatement of some of the relevant principles to be applied when determining whether equitable set-off is available.

The Court found that the claim for compensation under the first lease could be set-off against the unpaid rent under the second lease.

What is Set Off

The Court noted that, in substance, both claims arose out of ‘one continuing relationship affected by the [landlord’s] renovation of the shopping centre’.

Those principles are:

  • there must be a sufficient connection between the two claims
  • to be sufficiently connected, one claim must be said to ‘impeach’ or ‘go to the root of’ the other claim, such that it would be unfair for one claim to be allowed without accounting for the other
  • a set-off can arise where the claims are based on different legal instruments between the same parties
What is Set Off

Hawes v Dean

In the case of Hawes v Dean [2014] NSWCA 380, Justice Barrett noted that the “…two wrongs or defaults were so closely connected that a net position or result ought in equity to prevail between the parties because it would be unconscionable to allow one of them to insist on its legal right without first accommodating the other’s countervailing legal right.”

Justice Barrett concluded that: “It is the existence of that unconscionability that causes the first party’s claim to be “impeached” (that is, undermined and defeated) by the second party’s claim”.

You can read more about set-off here.

How can Prosper Law help?

Before taking steps to exercise a right of set-off, it is important to ensure that you have correctly identified the right that is relied upon. The best way to do this is to engage an Australian contracts lawyer.

Contact the team at Prosper Law today for a fixed-fee quote and first-class legal advice.

Farrah Motley | Director

PROSPER LAW – Australia’s Online Law Firm

M: 1300 003 077

E: farrah@prosperlaw.com.au

W: www.prosperlaw.com.au

A: Suite No. 99, Level 18, 324 Queen Street, Brisbane, Queensland Australia 4000

online law firm

Contact an Australian Business Lawyer Today.

Contact us for a free consultation

Lead Form - Hero Section - Header (#6)

Contact us for a free legal consultation

Lead From - Sidebar

About Prosper Law

We provide legal advice to business and individuals across Australia, no matter which State or Territory you are located. Our easy-to-access, online legal services mean that you can talk to our lawyers wherever you are, at a time that suits you.

Need Legal Assistance?

Don’t hesitate – reach out for your free legal assistance today. Your peace of mind is just a click or call away!

Check Out Our Latest Blog Posts

The options for workplace investigation outcomes

The options for workplace investigation outcomes

Workplace investigation outcomes are the actions taken by an employer in response to the outcome of a workplace investigation. Employers may need to take several steps to address misconduct allegations,

Witnesses & workplace investigations – a legal guide

Witnesses & workplace investigations – a legal guide

In workplace investigations, the testimonies of witnesses frequently serve as a key part of the investigation. Often, witness statements and interviews will have a significant impact on the outcome.These firsthand

Unfair Contract Terms & Small Businesses

Unfair Contract Terms & Small Businesses

Unfair contract terms create an unreasonable imbalance of power between contracting parties. Australian law prohibits unfair terms where a party to the agreement is a small business.As of November 2023,