4.9

Google Reviews

Need Help? Contact An Australian Business Lawyer Today 1300 003 077

BOOT Test: Why Enterprise Agreements Fail (2026 Update)

You can pay above the award, win the vote, and still have your enterprise agreement knocked back by the Fair Work Commission.

The reason is usually the better off overall test (the BOOT). Before the Commission approves an enterprise agreement, it must be satisfied that every award-covered employee (and every employee you could reasonably expect to hire) would be better off overall under your agreement than under the modern award. Not most of them. Each of them.

Most BOOT problems aren’t deliberate. They come from an assumption nobody tested, usually that a higher hourly rate covers everything. And since 2023 the stakes have changed. If the Commission has a BOOT concern, it no longer just asks you for undertakings. It can amend your agreement itself, even if you don’t consent (as ALDI found out in 2026).

The problems I see most often aren’t in the headline rate. They’re in the detail: a part-time clause that leaves the finish time open, an overtime trigger that quietly disappeared, or a site allowance nobody remembered was in the award.

What the BOOT actually compares

The BOOT compares what an employee would receive under your proposed agreement with what they would receive under the relevant modern award (Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), s 193). Passing it is a condition of approval (s 186(2)(d)).

The test applies to every ‘award covered employee’ (someone covered by the agreement and by a modern award for the work they do). It also applies to every ‘reasonably foreseeable employee’ – a person you don’t employ yet but could, in a classification the agreement covers. So an empty classification still gets tested.

The comparison is made at the ‘test time’, which is the day you lodge the approval application. Not the day bargaining started, and not the day of the vote.

And everything hangs off the modern award you compare against. Start with the wrong award or classification and the rest of the analysis is built on sand. Some businesses have more than one award in play. In one case, an equipment hire business earning about 30% of its revenue from domestic and unidentified customers was found to be in the general retail industry, even though most of its customers were trade (GJE Pty Ltd [2013] FWCFB 1705).

Q: Does every clause have to beat the award?

A: No. The Commission weighs the terms that are more beneficial against the terms that are less beneficial and forms an overall view (Armacell Australia Pty Ltd [2010] FWAFB 9985). A higher base rate can pay for lower penalty rates. It just has to actually pay for them.

Sharna Arnold is a Senior Paralegal at Prosper Law

How the Commission applies the BOOT (2026 update)

The Fair Work Legislation Amendment (Secure Jobs, Better Pay) Act 2022 changed how the BOOT is applied from 6 June 2023. Most of the changes help employers. One of them has a sting in the tail.

The helpful changes first. The Commission must make a global assessment, not a line-by-line comparison (s 193A(2)). It can look at classes of employees and assume the result holds for everyone in that class, unless there’s evidence to the contrary (s 193(7)). It must also consider the views of the employer, employees and bargaining representatives, and give primary consideration to views that employers and unions share (s 193A(3)–(4)).

The biggest practical change is that the Commission only considers patterns of work and types of employment that are reasonably foreseeable at the test time (s 193A(6)). Before 2023, employers were regularly asked for undertakings about hypothetical shifts nobody worked or planned to work. That’s no longer necessary.

Now the sting. The same Act gave the Commission power to approve an agreement with amendments that fix a BOOT concern (s 191A). Before 2023 the options were, broadly, undertakings or refusal. Now the Commission can specify the fix itself.

ALDI’s warehouse agreements show what that looks like. The agreements paid above the award and employees had voted for them. However, part-time warehouse employees had no guaranteed minimum hours, no fixed start and finish times and highly variable rosters. The Commission found some of them would be worse off overall despite the higher pay. ALDI declined to give an undertaking, so in January 2026 Deputy President Slevin approved the agreements with amendments directed at giving part-time employees more certainty about their hours (ALDI Foods Pty Ltd [2026] FWC 2). ALDI appealed. A Full Bench has since confirmed that the Commission doesn’t need the employer’s consent to make those amendments ([2026] FWCFB 134).

There are two lessons here. Higher pay won’t buy you out of a certainty problem. And if you won’t fix a BOOT issue, the Commission may fix it for you, on terms you didn’t choose.

Where it goes wrong: a worked example

Here’s the trap most employers fall into. (The figures are simplified for illustration. They aren’t taken from any particular award.)

Assume the award pays a base rate of $30 an hour, with Saturdays at 125% and Sundays at 150%. Your proposed agreement pays a flat $33 an hour (10% above the award) for all hours, with no weekend penalties. It feels generous, and most of your team would probably agree.

Roster (per week)Under the awardUnder the agreementDifference
38 hours, Monday to Friday$1,140$1,254+$114
24 weekday hours + 8 hours Saturday$1,020$1,056+$36
8 hours Saturday + 8 hours Sunday$660$528–$132

Seems fine, right? Two of the three rosters come out ahead, and your weekday staff (probably most of your workforce) are more than $100 a week better off.

It doesn’t matter. The weekend employee is $132 a week worse off, and the Commission doesn’t average. If any employee is not better off overall, the agreement doesn’t pass (Loaded Rates Agreements [2018] FWCFB 3610). One roster. One employee. That’s enough.

This isn’t hypothetical. In 2016, a Coles agreement that most of a 78,000-strong workforce had voted for was found not to pass the BOOT, because casual and part-time employees working nights and weekends were worse off. Coles argued that extra breaks and leave made up the difference. The Full Bench didn’t accept that. Some of those benefits were hard to value, and many weren’t used by everyone (defence service leave, for example). Coles declined to give undertakings and the agreement wasn’t approved (Hart v Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd [2016] FWCFB 2887).

Notice the middle row too. A margin of $36 a week is thin. If that employee picks up one Sunday shift instead of a weekday, or award rates rise at the Annual Wage Review before you lodge, the margin can disappear. (The Commission tests against award rates at the test time and won’t take known future award increases into account: Bunnings Group Ltd [2023] FWCFB 125.)

What happens if the Commission finds a BOOT problem

A BOOT concern doesn’t automatically mean starting again. But every way out costs you something.

The usual first step is an undertaking (a written, binding promise about how you’ll apply the agreement), such as a top-up payment or keeping an award penalty rate (s 190). There are limits. The Commission won’t accept an undertaking that changes the agreement so much it could have affected how employees voted (CFMMEU v C&H Acquisition Pty Ltd [2020] FWCFB 3134). It won’t accept one that relies on employees chasing up a shortfall themselves (SDA v Beechworth Bakery [2017] FWCFB 1664). And it isn’t the Commission’s job to keep negotiating with you until you get it right (AKN Pty Ltd t/a Aitkin Crane Services [2015] FWCFB 1833).

If you won’t give a satisfactory undertaking, the Commission can now approve the agreement with its own amendments under s 191A. You get to put your views. You don’t get a veto.

If neither route works, the agreement isn’t approved. That means going back to bargaining, explaining the revised terms and putting them to another vote. In the meantime, the award continues to apply.

There is one more exit, but don’t plan on it. The Commission can approve an agreement that fails the BOOT where there are exceptional circumstances and approval isn’t contrary to the public interest (s 189). The examples are genuinely exceptional: a not-for-profit around 500 km from the nearest town with four grant-funded employees (Milingimbi [2011] FWAA 1431), and a business hit by three natural disasters in quick succession, whose agreement was approved for 12 months only (Poolhaven [2011] FWAA 4036). Losing ground to competitors whose cheaper agreements were approved was not exceptional (Crawford Security & Investigations [2013] FWC 5858).

So what does all of this cost you? Time first. Every week the agreement sits unapproved is a week your new pay structure and rosters aren’t locked in, and neither is the protection from industrial action that an approved agreement gives you for its nominal term. Then money: re-modelling, legal fees and possibly a second ballot. And if an undertaking or amendment restores award penalties you thought the higher rate had bought out, you end up paying both. That’s a cost you never priced into the deal.

Approval isn’t always the end of it, either. If employees later work patterns that the Commission didn’t consider when it applied the BOOT, an employer, employee or union covered by the agreement can apply to have the BOOT reconsidered (s 227A). And if award base rates overtake your agreement’s base rates, employees must be paid at least the award base rate.

Prosper Law's legal team corporate shot, with experience including buying a business, deferred price arrangements, fixed price and earnout agreements

Where employers trip up

BOOT problems tend to grow out of a small number of assumptions. Some of the common ones include:

  • assuming a flat or loaded rate covers every penalty, loading and allowance. It usually works for a Monday to Friday day shift. It’s the employee working mostly nights, early mornings or weekends who comes out behind;
  • building casual-style flexibility into part-time employment, such as a set start time with an open-ended finish time, or no clear guaranteed minimum hours and days. After ALDI, expect the Commission to look hard at this;
  • losing an overtime trigger. A high ordinary rate doesn’t help if overtime isn’t paid after 38 hours a week, or for work outside the award’s span of ordinary hours;
  • getting the penalty rules wrong where they overlap (for example, whether a public holiday penalty replaces a weekend penalty or sits on top of it);
  • forgetting the smaller allowances: tools, uniforms, meals and travel, or site-specific ones like cold work in a warehouse. Each one is small. Together they can wipe out a thin margin;
  • relying on non-monetary benefits that are vague, discretionary or not available to the employees who are actually worse off. Where the dollar loss is significant, these rarely carry the day;
  • putting employment contract terms into the agreement. Restraints of trade, confidentiality and intellectual property clauses belong in the contract. In an agreement, they lose the Common Law ‘reasonableness’ filter, a breach can attract civil penalties, and they can count against you in the BOOT (Glen Eden Thoroughbreds [2010] FWA 7217);
  • including an opt-out clause and treating it as a benefit. The Federal Court has said a right not to be covered by the agreement isn’t a benefit at all (CFMEU v Deputy President Hamberger [2011] FCA 719); and
  • treating the vote as the finish line. Employee support matters, but the Commission applies the BOOT independently.

A top-up clause (sometimes called a reconciliation or ‘no disadvantage’ clause) can rescue a thin margin, but only if it’s drafted properly. If it only reconciles once a year, employees can be underpaid for months before anything is fixed, and the Commission may not be satisfied it does the job. If it requires the employee to raise a grievance before they’re paid the difference, it’s unlikely to be accepted at all (SDA v Beechworth Bakery [2017] FWCFB 1664). The safer approach is a regular, automatic reconciliation, with the back-payment as your obligation rather than something the employee has to chase.

The contract terms point deserves a word of its own, because it’s an easy mistake for a business that wants everything in one document. My view is simple: keep restraints, confidentiality and IP in the employment contract, where they’re tested on Common Law principles, and keep the enterprise agreement for pay and conditions.

Before your agreement goes to a vote

Fixing a BOOT problem before the vote is a drafting exercise. Fixing it after the vote is a negotiation with the Commission. This is the order I’d work through:

  1. Confirm the award (or awards) and the classification of every role the agreement covers, including roles you don’t currently fill.
  2. List every pattern of work the agreement allows that is reasonably foreseeable: weekends, nights, public holidays, overtime, split shifts, and casual and part-time engagement.
  3. Model the worst-placed employee in each group, not the average. If a part-timer who mostly works Sundays comes out behind, that’s your answer.
  4. Write down what any loaded rate is meant to absorb (penalties, overtime, allowances) and the roster assumptions behind it.
  5. Turn non-monetary benefits into enforceable entitlements (a defined amount of extra leave, not a promise to ‘consider’ flexibility).
  6. Explain the trade-offs to employees in plain terms, with examples. They’re often the first to spot the shift that always runs into overtime.
  7. Decide in advance which undertakings you’d be prepared to give if asked, and what each would cost.
  8. After approval, check your rates against the award after every Annual Wage Review.

Q: Does the BOOT apply to annualised salaries?

A: Not as a legal test. The BOOT applies to enterprise agreements. But running a BOOT-style comparison on an award-covered employee’s salary is one of the quickest ways to find an underpayment before it turns into a claim. Once overtime, penalties, allowances and leave loading are added back in, a ‘generous’ salary can land much closer to the award than you’d expect.

Farrah Motley is an Australian Legal Practitioner and the Director of Prosper Law

How can Prosper Law help?

We help employers with award coverage, enterprise agreement drafting, BOOT modelling and Fair Work Commission approval applications, including responding when the Commission raises a BOOT concern. If your agreement is heading to a vote, talk to us first. It’s far cheaper to fix a roster problem in a spreadsheet than in front of the Commission. Contact our employment team.

About the Author

Picture of Farrah Motley
Farrah Motley
Director of Prosper Law. Farrah founded Prosper online law firm in 2021. She wanted to create a better way of doing legal work and a better experience for customers of legal services.

Contact an Australian Business Lawyer Today.

Contact us for a free consultation

Contact Us For A Free Legal Consultation
About Prosper Law

We provide legal advice to business and individuals across Australia, no matter which State or Territory you are located. Our easy-to-access, online legal services mean that you can talk to our lawyers wherever you are, at a time that suits you.

4.9

Google Reviews

Get Your Free Guide Now
Need Legal Assistance?

Don’t hesitate – reach out for your free legal assistance today. Your peace of mind is just a click or call away!

Check Out Our Latest Blog Posts

Employment Law For Employers

Payday Super: Are You Actually Compliant?

Payday superannuation came into effect on 1 July 2026. Employers must now pay superannuation guarantee (SG) contributions each time they pay wages, and the contribution generally needs to reach the

Sharna Arnold
Contracts

Contractor vs Employee: Getting It Right

Plenty of Australian businesses rely on contractors. It is a flexible way to bring in skills, cover busy periods or grow without taking on permanent staff. The problem is that