Most guides on flexible work requests explain the same checklist: who is eligible, the 21-day deadline and what counts as a reasonable business ground. That checklist matters, and we have summarised it near the end of this article.
In our practice, though, where we act for both employers and employees, the requests that turn into problems tend not to be the routine ones. They often arrive in the middle of something else, such as a restructure, a return from illness or a dispute that is already heading towards an exit. Employers who read the request on its own, as an HR form to approve or decline, may respond to the wrong question.
A request is often part of a bigger conversation
Before deciding how to respond, it helps to ask what else is happening with this employee right now. These are the four situations we see most often.
1. A restructure or redeployment
We regularly advise employees whose roles are affected by a restructure. They may be offered alternative roles on hybrid terms, with a set number of office days recommended under a policy, while their contract names the employer’s office as their place of work.
Working from home may be the condition that matters most to the employee personally, but it may not be more important to them than their pay or redundancy entitlements. In that situation, we may suggest a formal request under section 65 of the Fair Work Act, rather than treating working from home as a deal-breaker, so that any arrangement agreed can be documented rather than resting on a policy that could change.
For employers, two things follow. First, in a redeployment, the flexible work request and the role offer are likely to be read together. Where redundancy pay applies (generally, for employers with 15 or more employees), an employer can apply to the Fair Work Commission to reduce it if the employer has obtained “other acceptable employment” for the employee, and factors such as location and working arrangements may be relevant to whether a role is acceptable. Second, an employee with advice is likely to want terms recorded in a contract variation, not a policy. Being ready to document an agreed arrangement may help an offer land.
2. A return from illness, injury or leave
Requests also often overlap with a return to work after illness or injury. Medical certificates may set out restrictions, such as working from home or avoiding travel, and the wording is not always clear. An employer and an employee may read the same certificate quite differently.
A medical restriction and a flexible work request are separate things. Temporary restrictions are usually managed under work health and safety and anti-discrimination obligations (and workers’ compensation return-to-work obligations, if the injury or illness is work-related), which may require reasonable adjustments regardless of the section 65 process. A section 65 request is a written request for an ongoing change. Both can apply at the same time. Where a certificate is unclear, it is likely to be better to ask the employee to obtain clarification from their doctor than to assume either way.
3. A dispute that may end in an exit
When an employment relationship is already strained, a list of requested adjustments can mean different things. Sometimes it is a sincere attempt to make the job work. Sometimes the employee’s preferred outcome is a negotiated exit, and the requests form part of that conversation. In our experience, an employee in this position may be concerned that the employer will agree to every adjustment and the relationship will continue to deteriorate.
Employers in this position may find it useful to separate the formal record from the negotiation. A clear, reasoned written response to any request may help protect the business if the matter reaches a tribunal. A separate without prejudice discussion can then explore whether the employee wants to stay. Treating the request as purely administrative may miss the point of what is being asked.
4. A new office attendance policy
A return-to-office direction may trigger several requests at once. The Commission has indicated that a policy or enterprise agreement clause does not, on its own, answer a request. In Chandler v Westpac Banking Corporation [2025] FWC 3115, it ordered a bank to grant a work-from-home request despite an office attendance requirement, and in Paper Australia Pty Ltd v May [2025] FWCFB 224 the Full Bench confirmed that an agreement term prohibiting an arrangement cannot by itself supply reasonable business grounds. If you are changing your attendance expectations, it may be worth planning how you will assess the individual requests that are likely to follow.
How to read a request before you respond
The table below sets out what a request may be about in each of these situations, and what is worth checking before you reply.
| Situation | What the request may be about | What to check first |
|---|---|---|
| Restructure or redeployment | Securing terms for a new role, or the redundancy position | Whether the role offer and the request should be answered together and documented in a contract variation |
| Return from illness or injury | A temporary medical need, an ongoing change, or both | What the certificate actually says, and whether a separate section 65 request has been made |
| Strained relationship or complaint | Making the job work, or negotiating an exit | What outcome the employee wants, and keeping the formal response separate from any settlement discussion |
| New attendance policy | Keeping an existing arrangement | The evidence for your business grounds for this role, not the policy in general |
What employees are being advised, and what it means for you
Because we also act for employees, we have a good sense of the advice they are likely to receive. Employers may find it useful to expect the following:
- Formal requests: employees may be advised to make a written section 65 request, so the 21-day deadline and the reasonable business grounds test apply.
- Careful meetings: employees may attend meetings to listen and ask questions, but decline to agree to anything on the spot and respond in writing afterwards. A request for an immediate decision is unlikely to get one.
- A written record: employees are often advised to record why a role or arrangement does not suit them. If the matter reaches the Commission, your written reasons may be compared with theirs.
- Documentation over policy: agreed terms are more likely to be requested in a contract variation than left in a policy.
None of this needs to be adversarial. In our experience, an employer who engages in writing, explains its reasons and offers a documented trial or compromise is more likely to resolve the request without a dispute.

The legal minimum, in brief
Whatever the context, the Fair Work Act process still applies to every eligible request. In summary, it requires the following:
| Requirement | Summary |
|---|---|
| Who can request | Employees with at least 12 months’ continuous service (or regular and systematic casuals with 12 months’ service and a reasonable expectation of ongoing work) who are pregnant, parents or carers of a child of school age or younger, carers, have a disability, are 55 or older, or are experiencing or supporting someone experiencing family and domestic violence |
| Your response | In writing within 21 days |
| Refusing | Only after discussing the request, trying in good faith to reach agreement and considering the consequences for the employee, and only on reasonable business grounds. The written response must explain the reasons and business grounds, set out any changes you would agree to (or say there are none), and explain how the decision can be disputed |
| Disputes | If the dispute cannot be resolved at the workplace, the Fair Work Commission can conciliate and, if needed, arbitrate and make orders, including that the request be granted or granted with changes |
The Fair Work Ombudsman sets out these steps in more detail. For employers with staff in Victoria, a proposed state right to work from home up to two days a week, where reasonable (the Equal Opportunity Amendment (Work from Home) Bill 2026) lapsed on 3 November 2026 and is not law at the time of writing, though it may return after the state election.
Next step
Before responding to any request, write down what else is currently happening with that employee. If the answer is “a restructure”, “a medical certificate” or “a complaint”, the request is unlikely to be routine.
One thing to consider is whether the response and any related offer, return-to-work plan or settlement discussion should be prepared together, so they are consistent.
Prosper Law is an online law firm that advises employers Australia-wide on a fixed-fee basis. We can review a request and your draft response before it goes out, advise where it overlaps with a restructure or return to work, and represent you in the Fair Work Commission if a dispute arises. Call us on 1300 003 077 or request a fixed-fee quote.
Frequently asked questions
Is a medical certificate saying "work from home" a flexible work request?
Not usually. A certificate sets out temporary restrictions, which you may need to accommodate under other obligations. A section 65 request is a separate written request for an ongoing change, although an employee may make one at the same time.
Can an employee make a flexible work request during a redundancy process?
Yes, if they are eligible. The request still needs a response within 21 days, and how it is handled may be relevant to whether an alternative role is seen as acceptable.
Should we agree to a request just to avoid a dispute?
Not necessarily. Agreeing may be sensible, but if the relationship is already strained, it is worth understanding what the employee wants before deciding. A documented trial with a review date may be a practical middle ground.
Can we record a work-from-home arrangement in a contract variation?
Yes. This is likely to give both parties more certainty than a policy, but it may also make the arrangement harder to change later, so the terms are worth getting right.
Last updated: 12 November 2026
This article is general information current at the date above and is not legal advice. Please contact us for advice on your situation.
About the Author

Farrah Motley
Contact an Australian Business Lawyer Today.
Contact us for a free consultation

